Shenzhen Trilateral Summit : Declaration of peace without a plan for peace
R K Raina
New Delhi, Nov 20 (UNI) The much-hyped trilateral meeting between the leaders of the United States, Russia and China in Shenzhen on 19 November 2026 was expected to produce something significant for the future of global peace and security. Instead, the joint declaration has raised a more fundamental question: is the world order going to be decided by strategic competition among major powers or by their willingness to take concrete steps towards peace?
The declaration refers to stopping the two devastating wars, ensuring strategic stability and international security, reforming the United Nations, securing energy supplies and adopting a common approach to preventing nuclear war. These are undoubtedly critical issues, but the question is how far they have been addressed through any meaningful commitment or concrete course of action. All these subjects have been discussed repeatedly at international forums and bilateral meetings, without producing any consequential results.
The expectation from a summit involving three of the world's most powerful leaders was therefore much greater than another declaration of principles on which everyone can agree. The real test was whether they could move beyond familiar diplomatic commitments and agree on a time-bound action plan to address the conflicts, insecurity and economic suffering that the world is witnessing today. Without such a commitment, even the most comprehensive declaration will remain a repetition of familiar positions rather than a meaningful step towards peace.
There is no meaningful discussion of peace without addressing the ongoing wars in Ukraine and Iran. If three leaders representing the world's most powerful military and economic establishments cannot agree on even a roadmap to stop these conflicts, what is the practical significance of their declaration? Good intentions without an action plan will remain a matter of academic interest.
Comparisons with the 1945 Yalta Summit between the United States, Britain and the Soviet union are misplaced. The world of 1945 was emerging from a devastating global war. Military power was the principal instrument for deciding strategic interests, and the victorious powers were negotiating the structure of the post-war international order.
The world of 2026 is fundamentally different. Military power can destroy, disrupt economies and threaten the survival of nations, but it cannot necessarily achieve strategic objectives or deliver a sustainable political outcome. The ongoing conflicts in Ukraine and Iran demonstrate this reality. The capacity to continue a war does not automatically translate into the capacity to end it on acceptable terms.
The three leaders may have come together under the language of peace, but their individual strategic interests remain different. What was discussed behind closed doors may also be different from what has appeared in the declaration. Its real significance will be judged by subsequent developments, not by the diplomatic presentation of the meeting.
The United States, Russia and China have their own geopolitical and geoeconomic priorities. Their common interest appears to be maintaining influence over global energy supplies, economic arrangements and the strategic decisions of other countries. However, this does not mean that they share a common vision for the world.
The countries suffering from the consequences of war and economic disruption, whether in Asia, Europe, the Middle East or Africa, cannot remain passive spectators to decisions taken by three powerful leaders. Nor can they be expected to accept every strategic understanding reached among them.
The present conflicts have exposed the limitations of all three powers. The United States has not been able to bring the conflict involving Iran to an end. Russia has not achieved a decisive political resolution in Ukraine, while China has maintained its economic and strategic position without demonstrating an ability to bring either conflict to a conclusion. None has been able to prevent the suffering of ordinary people.
The three leaders may represent major military and economic powers, but their inability to stop wars raises serious questions about the actual limits of their influence. Their strength is evident in their capacity to shape events, but their inability to deliver peace is equally evident.
If military power alone could decide the strategic interests of the world, the strongest military would dictate its future. Similarly, if GDP alone could determine the world order, the strongest economy would decide how other nations should conduct their affairs.
Neither proposition holds true today.
The world is increasingly influenced by people, public opinion, digital communication and the ability of societies to stand against decisions they consider unjust. The spirit of people and their willingness to question established power structures have become important factors in international relations. In today's digital world, no country can assume that its economic or military strength will automatically secure acceptance of its policies.
Strategic competition is changing every day, and its direction is not necessarily reflected in the agenda placed on the table at international summits.
Another fundamental issue is the credibility of the United Nations. Its Security Council remains highly imbalanced, with veto powers concentrated in the hands of five permanent members. The problem becomes particularly serious when the national interests of these very members are involved in a conflict that requires international intervention.
A system in which a country can influence or obstruct decisions concerning a conflict involving its own interests cannot provide an impartial foundation for global peace.
Meaningful reform must include greater representation for Asia, Africa and Latin America, reflecting the population, diversity and growing economic and political importance of these regions. India, in particular, has a legitimate claim to a greater role in international decision-making. The role that India is playing while standing for the largest successful democracy in the world itself makes it at number one position among the existing Security Council members.
The three permanent members participating in the Shenzhen Summit are unlikely to willingly surrender their privileged positions. However, selective support for UN reform, without addressing the imbalance in its decision-making structure, cannot restore its credibility.
There is also no unanimity in the international community on condemning terrorism, violence, economic deprivation and the loss of innocent lives. The world needs a common commitment to humanity rather than selective positions determined by political convenience.
The real question is not what the three leaders have declared, but what they are prepared to do. At least the United States and Russia have the direct capacity to take immediate decisions concerning the wars in which they are involved. If they are unwilling to use their influence to stop the killing and suffering, no declaration on peace can carry much weight.
The expectations created by the media and comparisons with historic summits are often disconnected from the actual workings of diplomacy. A summit is a meeting of competing interests, not necessarily a platform for resolving the world's problems.
Ultimately, strategic competition, rather than a peace declaration, is what will continue to influence the future world order. But even this competition cannot guarantee that the interests of individual powers will prevail. The world is no longer governed by military might or economic strength alone. It is increasingly shaped by the collective voice of its people and their determination to question what is wrong.
The Shenzhen Summit may have demonstrated that three major powers can sit together. What it has not demonstrated is that they can act together to stop a war. Until that distinction is addressed, the declaration will remain a statement of intent, while strategic competition continues to decide the course of the world.
(The author is a former diplomat. The views are personal.)
UNI XC RSA