Criticise decisions, not institutions: CJI Surya Kant on democratic accountability
Dharamshala, Nov 22 (UNI) Chief Justice of India Surya Kant on Sunday underscored the importance of safeguarding democratic institutions while asserting that citizens have every right to criticise decisions taken by constitutional bodies, but should not let disagreements undermine the institutions themselves, which are vital to sustaining public confidence and democracy.
Interacting with students on the sidelines of the 10th convocation of the Central University of Himachal Pradesh (CUHP), where he was the chief guest, Justice Kant observed that people often failed to distinguish between a decision and the institution behind it, a tendency that could weaken institutions essential to sustaining democracy.
Addressing 702 graduating students, Justice Kant also urged them to pursue their ambitions with patience, resilience and humility, drawing parallels between life's challenges and the winding mountain roads of Himachal Pradesh.
"The road to any destination in the mountains is seldom straight," he said, encouraging students not to measure their achievements against those of others, particularly through comparisons on social media.
"A mountain does not become any smaller in its stature simply because another peak happens to be taller than that mountain," he said, stressing that individual journeys and achievements should be valued on their own merit.
Emphasising the importance of collaboration, Justice Kant said success is rarely achieved in isolation and that willingness to listen, work with others and learn from them is a strength rather than a weakness.
"No one climbs a mountain entirely alone," he said, adding that students should remember those who helped them along the way and extend support to others when they reached their own milestones.
"When you find yourself at the summit of some personal or professional achievement, remember to look back, extend a hand and help someone else to climb," he told the graduates.
The convocation was held at the auditorium of Government Degree College, Dharamshala, where 702 students received degrees and 32 gold medals were awarded, including 23 to women.
Congratulating the graduating students, Justice Kant expressed particular pride in the women achievers, saying their success reflected an emerging India in which daughters are increasingly being given equal opportunities to excel. He acknowledged the contribution of parents, families and teachers and thanked Vice-Chancellor Prof Sat Prakash Bansal for creating opportunities for students.
Recalling his seven-month tenure as Chief Justice of the Himachal Pradesh High Court beginning in October 2018, Justice Kant said he is delighted to return to Dharamshala and described Himachal Pradesh as a place that felt like home.
Chief Minister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu told graduates that their education carried a responsibility towards society and the country, asserting that a nation's strength lay in its educated citizens.
He said the state government's priorities were education, healthcare and strengthening the rural economy to ensure young people could access opportunities without having to migrate and that financial constraints did not interrupt their education.
Sukhu said Himachal Pradesh has attained full literacy, English-medium teaching had been introduced in government schools and 156 schools had been affiliated with the CBSE. He also cited the state's education loan scheme, under which students could avail loans at one per cent interest, and said efforts are underway to expand access to science, artificial intelligence and robotics.
Governor Kavinder Gupta urged students to uphold truth, values and character, saying talent could help a person advance but character made them credible. He called for greater emphasis on skill development, the National Education Policy 2020 and the Indian Knowledge System, while urging the university to promote Himalayan studies and conservation, including environmental and water-resource protection.
The ceremony was attended by Deputy Chief Minister Mukesh Agnihotri, Chief Justice of the Himachal Pradesh High Court Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia, university Chancellor Dr Harmohinder Singh Bedi, Association of Indian Universities Secretary General Dr Pankaj Mittal and other dignitaries.
The graduating cohort included 584 postgraduate students, 29 undergraduates and 48 PhD scholars, besides diploma holders.UNI AAB